Current:Home > NewsDavid Byrne: Why radio should pay singers like Beyoncé and Willie Nelson -Horizon Finance School
David Byrne: Why radio should pay singers like Beyoncé and Willie Nelson
Rekubit View
Date:2025-04-07 11:40:52
When I tell friends I went to Washington, D.C., to lobby on behalf of the American Music Fairness Act – which will enable musicians to get paid for radio play – they uniformly respond with a look of shock.
“What, you don’t get paid when you’re played on the radio?”“Nope, as a performer I get nothing.”“Does anybody get paid?”“Songwriters and music publishers, but not the artist you hear singing it.”
And then I tell them that some of the only other countries that don’t pay musicians for radio play are our friends in Cuba, Iran and North Korea. Then they give me an eye roll that says, “That’s crazy!” China used to not pay, but they pay now. Russia pays! Nice bedfellows, eh? Nice example to the rest of the world!
Aretha Franklin had a worldwide hit with “Respect” – but she didn’t write the song, Otis Redding did, so she got paid nothing – nothing! – for decades of U.S. radio airplay. That’s what I’m talking about.
Sinead O’Connor’s “Nothing Compares 2 U”? Nothing to her. Karen O “Under Pressure”? Nope. Willie Nelson “Always on My Mind”? Nada. Cat Power on “Ballad of a Thin Man”? Nix. “Umbrella” and Rihanna? Uh-uh. “Irreplaceable” Beyoncé? Never. “Get the Party Started” Pink? Nope. The list goes on and on.
How did this happen? When it began, radio in the United States was positioned to musicians as a promotional tool to sell their sheet music; before recordings were available that was how music was “sold.” Music played on the radio was often performed live in those days. The artists were singing and playing live while you heard it in your home.
It was Bing Crosby who discovered (and helped finance) tape recordings of his shows so he didn't have to be there for every broadcast; instead he could be with his great love, the golf course. Credit the advent of tape recording in the United States to the popularity of golf!
Radio play was once intended as a promotional tool
Records in various formats became popular, and radio play of these recordings was similarly positioned as a promotional tool. As recording artists we were fed this same justification for why we weren’t going to be paid for radio play – exposure that promotes your record sales and your live shows.
There’s a kernel of truth there, but it seemed unfair even then. We were indeed making money from record sales back in the day, so we went along to get along. But it never really made sense.
Every other democracy in the world has corrected this injustice, which makes it plain to us artists that it doesn’t have to be this way in our country, either.
We love playing music and recording it. It’s thrilling and fulfilling, but it is also our livelihood. Like anyone else we have come to realize we should get paid for our hard work, our investment, our creative energy and inspirations.
'This is a Beyoncé album':Beyoncé pushes the confines of genre with 'Cowboy Carter.' Country will be better for it.
Musicians are small business owners
We are, most of us, small businesses, entrepreneurs, risk takers – we employ other musicians and a whole ecology of other professionals to run those businesses. Making music is such an amazing thing, but it’s not always easy. It takes a lot of work, and it doesn’t always pay as much as its worth.
Getting paid for radio play has knock-on benefits as well. Because the United States doesn’t pay foreign performers for radio play, some other countries reciprocate, tit for tat. They are holding an estimated $300 million a year that is due to U.S. artists – and that will be released if the situation here changes when U.S. radio starts paying their artists. This has been going on so long that some countries, like France, funnel that money to organizations that promote their own artists, rather than having it just sit in a bank.
Lyrical letdown:In Taylor Swift's 'Tortured Poets,' the torture is in the songwriting
How much would artists get from U.S. broadcasts? The estimate is about $500 million. So, after unlocking international performance royalties, it’s at least $800 million total. A lot. It would get divided among the performer, the backing band and their label. Full disclosure ‒ I personally stand to benefit as well.
Naturally the big broadcasters, and there are only a handful of them, are fighting this tooth and nail. They’ll say it will hurt small businesses, but the bill is structured so that small broadcasters get a huge break, as do religious broadcasters and public radio. It’s really about the big commercial chain broadcasters, who are in fact making a lot of money.
The big broadcasters naturally still use the “exposure” and “promotion” argument, which isn’t completely untrue. I witnessed “Burning Down the House” become a hit due to radio play. But promotion like that is about introducing new music to an audience. Most of the songs played on the radio now are old, and record stores are hard to find these days. So where’s the promotion?
I’ll bet there’s a worry on the part of our lawmakers that these big broadcasters might not look kindly on a representative who voted for this bill. Just sayin’. But then look how many musicians there are and how vocal they can be. Do our representatives really want to go up against a bunch of small business people?
I went to Washington some years ago when a similar bill came up. It didn’t pass, but the good news is that this one, the American Music Fairness Act (AMFA), is better. It’s a bipartisan bill, which is rare these days, so there’s that to celebrate as well.
I’m thankful this has not become a political football like so much else. AMFA is supported on both sides of the aisle – how about that! So, c’mon Washington, let’s get it done.
Singer and songwriter David Byrne is a founding member of Talking Heads and a member of the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame.
veryGood! (729)
Related
- The White House is cracking down on overdraft fees
- A New Study Revealed Big Underestimates of Greenland Ice Loss—and the Power of New Technologies to Track the Changes
- What songs did Usher sing for his 2024 Super Bowl halftime show? See the setlist from his iconic performance.
- How to make overnight oats: Use this recipe for a healthy grab-and-go breakfast
- John Galliano out at Maison Margiela, capping year of fashion designer musical chairs
- 2024 NBA All-Star Game weekend: Live stream, TV, dunk contest, 3-point contest, rosters
- Environmental groups sue to force government to finalize ship speed rules that protect rare whales
- The 'food' you see on-screen often isn't real food. Not so, in 'The Taste of Things'
- Rams vs. 49ers highlights: LA wins rainy defensive struggle in key divisional game
- Disneyland performers seek to have union protections like other park employees
Ranking
- Realtor group picks top 10 housing hot spots for 2025: Did your city make the list?
- Chiefs Super Bowl parade live updates: Police say three detained after shooting
- ‘Lead or Lose!’ Young People Arrested at Biden’s Campaign Headquarters Call for Climate Action and a Ceasefire
- Kansas City Chiefs Super Bowl rally shooting stemmed from personal dispute: Live updates
- Warm inflation data keep S&P 500, Dow, Nasdaq under wraps before Fed meeting next week
- When will the Fed cut interest rates in 2024? Here's what experts now say and the impact on your money.
- Alabama Senate votes to change archives oversight after LGBTQ+ lecture
- Matt Damon improvised this line in Ben Affleck's Dunkin' commercial
Recommendation
The Super Bowl could end in a 'three
Palestinians living in US will be shielded from deportation, the White House says
Real estate company CoStar bolts Washington, D.C., for Virginia
Putin says Russia prefers Biden to Trump because he’s ‘more experienced and predictable’
Questlove charts 50 years of SNL musical hits (and misses)
Anti-abortion ads used location data from 600 Planned Parenthood locations, senator says
How to keep yourself safe from romance scams this Valentine’s Day
$5 for desk rent - before inflation: 3rd graders learn hard lessons to gain financial literacy